"Are carbs bad for you?" is one of the questions I hear most often in my weight loss consultations. The short answer is no. Carbohydrates are not inherently bad. They are your body's primary source of energy, and the right types of carbohydrates play a useful role in gut health and long-term wellbeing. The question is not carbohydrates themselves, but the type, amount, and context in which we eat them.
Not All Carbohydrates Are Equal
Carbohydrates fall into two broad categories, and understanding the difference is key:
- Complex carbohydrates: whole grains (oats, brown rice, quinoa), legumes (chickpeas, lentils), vegetables, and fruits. These are rich in fibre and tend to release energy more slowly.
- Refined carbohydrates: white bread, pastries, sugary cereals, biscuits, and fizzy drinks. These have been stripped of much of their fibre and nutrients, and tend to be digested quickly.
When people say "carbs are bad," they are usually referring to refined carbohydrates, and they have a point. Diets high in refined carbs are associated with weight gain and a higher risk of type 2 diabetes. But cutting out all carbohydrates, including the complex ones, removes a valuable source of fibre, B vitamins, and sustained energy.
Carbohydrates and Weight Loss
Low-carb diets like keto have gained popularity for weight loss, and some people lose weight on them in the short term. However, early weight loss often comes from water loss and eating less overall rather than any magic of cutting carbs specifically. Research suggests that overall diet quality and how sustainable your eating pattern is matter more than any single macronutrient.
In my practice, I find that clients who include complex carbohydrates in their meals tend to feel more satisfied, notice steadier energy through the day, and are more likely to keep up their eating habits long term. Restrictive approaches that eliminate entire food groups tend to lead to cycles of restriction and overeating.
For practical guidance on sustainable approaches, read my guide on healthy weight loss tips.
Carbohydrates and Blood Sugar
For anyone with an interest in diabetes or PCOS, the type of carbohydrate matters. Higher-fibre options such as oats, sweet potatoes, and legumes are generally digested more slowly than options like white rice or sugary snacks. If you have a diagnosed condition, I work alongside your doctor on anything involving your medication or monitoring, and I do not interpret blood results.
Pairing carbohydrates with protein and healthy fats also tends to make a meal more filling. For example, having oats with nuts and seeds (like my Overnight Oats with Flaxseed, Berries & Cinnamon) is a more satisfying choice than a bowl of sugary cereal.
For more on this topic, see my article on blood sugar and everyday food choices.
Carbohydrates and Gut Health
Fibre, found in plant-based carbohydrates, is important for gut health. It feeds the beneficial bacteria in your gut microbiome, supports regular bowel movements, and is associated with a lower risk of bowel cancer. Most adults in the UK eat less fibre than national guidance recommends.
Cutting carbohydrates drastically often means cutting fibre, which can contribute to constipation, bloating, and a less diverse gut microbiome. For more on this, read about the benefits of fibre and gut health and the microbiome.
How to Get Carbohydrates Right
Rather than cutting carbs, focus on choosing the right ones:
- Swap refined for whole: brown rice instead of white, wholemeal bread instead of white, whole oats instead of instant.
- Pair with protein and fat: this tends to keep you fuller for longer.
- Include plenty of vegetables: these are carbohydrates too, packed with fibre and micronutrients.
- Watch portions, not categories: a moderate portion of complex carbs at each meal is a sensible approach for most people.
It also helps to remember that carbohydrate foods are rarely just carbohydrate. Beans bring protein and fibre, wholegrain bread brings B vitamins and minerals, and fruit brings vitamin C. Thinking about the whole food, rather than the single nutrient, makes everyday choices simpler and less anxious.
Matching Carbohydrates to Your Day
Rather than fixating on rigid macronutrient counting, I find it more useful to think about how your carbohydrate choices fit the shape of your day. Starchy, fibre-rich whole foods make a good base for most people, and how much you want on any given day depends on how active you are.
A simple, practical way to think about it:
- Around exercise: If you are active, a wholegrain option such as porridge oats or a slice of dense rye sourdough with eggs, before or after a session, is an easy way to fuel and recover.
- Sedentary work days: On days dominated by sitting at a desk, you may find you naturally want less of the starchy element of your meal and more vegetables, protein, and healthy fats.
- Evening meals: Despite the popular myth that carbohydrates eaten in the evening are automatically stored as fat, including a sensible portion of sweet potato, lentils, or brown basmati rice at dinner is perfectly fine and can make an evening meal more satisfying.
When swapping to wholegrains still leaves you battling an afternoon slump or evening cravings, general rules may only take you so far. You are welcome to book a consultation via my services page or get in touch through contact to look at how your meals fit your daily routine.



